A Plague on Plagiarism

Magpie

I don’t understand why a poet would plagiarise another poet’s work. It goes so deeply against the reasons why people are drawn to poetry, both as readers and writers. It’s a betrayal of another and it’s a betrayal of self. It’s sad and it’s despicable. I suppose in the poetry community it’s just about the worse thing you can do. The financial rewards of writing poetry are not huge, certainly not worth risking one’s reputation for, because poets exposed as plagiarists pretty much become persona non grata to other poets. It’s worse than being a drugs cheat in athletics. You would have to be really lost to do it.

One of the worst ways in which plagiarism takes place, because of the intimacy and the direct betrayal of trust, is when a poet steals a fellow poet’s work in a poetry writing group or workshop, and even more so if it is the workshop leader actually doing the stealing! Real poets don’t magpie.

I run poetry writing groups in Bristol. Amongst the ground rules, discussed from time to time and always when a new person comes into the group, are the importance of confidentiality and the absolute prohibition against ripping off the work of fellow group members. Happily, plagiarism’s never been a problem for our groups.

Sadly, I’ve recently heard of a number of instances where plagiarism has taken place in poetry workshops, which is what prompts me to write this.

I would advise anyone attending a poetry workshop to raise the issue at the start of the workshop by reminding the group about the importance of respect, confidentiality and the prohibition against plagiarism, which includes nicking a line and altering it just a little bit. It might not stop a determined plagiarist but hopefully it will give them pause to consider what they’re doing.

And if anyone tells you it’s not plagiarism if the line concerned hasn’t been published, they are wrong and it is.

Be safe out there!

 

Published by

2 thoughts on “A Plague on Plagiarism

  1. I’ve often wondered about how it works if you incorporate a line of poetry of someone else’s in a poem, as a prompt, or a paean to that poet. I was part of a poetry workshop where we were provided a stack of poetry books and asked, as an exercise to add lines from those books to our poems. I’ve actually been to poetry events where two poets riff on each other uses bits form each other’s poems. Obviously they give each other permission. I liked the work that came out of this particular workshop I was in, but I felt funny about performing it in public. It’s a little awkward to preface a poem with “I used this line of this poet in my poem.” Or even these three poems include lines from Poet One, Poet Two, and Poet Three.” Because then I would need to specify which lines.

    Like

    1. Agreed, it has to feel right, above all else, and how poets who plagiarise can justify what they’ve done to the part of them that writes is hard to imagine.

      I would be wary of workshop prompts or assignments that encourage you to put other people’s lines in your poem, as it’s easy to forget, over time, what you actually wrote yourself, and assume that it’s all your work. That’s also why it’s important to attribute lines to their source in any notebooks you keep.

      I’m often inspired by a line from another writer or thinker, but always include it as a epigraph, or acknowledge the source – ie ‘after …. ‘.

      Deborah

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s